Step back in time with us as we unravel the comedic brilliance of “Arsenic and Old Lace” — a film that’s as charming as it is dark.
Welcome to NO NOTES, the show where three cerebral cinephiles take a break from chatting about guilty pleasures to discuss cinematic treasures. Each month, we’ll take turns selecting a film we believe to be virtually flawless, one that had a significant impact on our lives and/or helped shape the film lovers we became.
Join us for Kelly’s pick as she brings us the cinematic equivalent of a warm cup of hot cocoa on a chilly Fall evening. It’s the perfct pick for spooky season. Listen as we lobby for you to add this impossibly entertaining, endearing, and wildly funny—with just a hint of wicked—Capra classic to your watchlist this October.
Arsenic and Old Lace is a film that has stood the test of time with its unique blend of dark comedy and heartwarming charm. This classic movie, directed by Frank Capra, continues to enchant audiences with its clever script, impeccable comedic timing, and unforgettable performances, particularly by the legendary Cary Grant.
For those unfamiliar with the film, Arsenic and Old Lace is a masterclass in how to balance humor with darker themes. The story revolves around Mortimer Brewster, played by Cary Grant, who discovers that his sweet, elderly aunts are not as innocent as they seem. As the plot unfolds, Mortimer finds himself entangled in a web of murder, madness, and mayhem, all delivered with a light-hearted touch that makes the film a perennial favorite.
What makes the film truly remarkable is its ability to make audiences laugh while dealing with themes that, in lesser hands, could have been unsettling.
The film’s genius lies in its execution, from the witty dialogue to the stellar performances of its cast. Cary Grant’s portrayal of Mortimer is particularly noteworthy; his physical comedy and expressive face bring a unique energy to the role that elevates the film to new heights.
Our discussion also highlighted the film’s meta elements, which were ahead of its time. The playful nods to the audience, and the clever use of theatrical conventions make Arsenic and Old Lace a film that rewards multiple viewings. Each time you watch, there’s something new to appreciate, whether it’s the subtleties of the performances or the intricacies of the plot.
As we explored in the episode, this classic gem is more than just a comedy; it’s a celebration of the quirks and eccentricities that make us human. It’s a reminder that even in a story about murder, there’s room for warmth and kindness.
This film is a testament to the power of cinema to entertain, to provoke thought, and to bring joy to audiences across generations.
As Kelly argues for Arsenic and Old Laces‘s place in the hallowed halls of cinematic perfection, she says:
“We watch ARSENIC AND OLD LACE every year, and every time, I marvel at the meta jokes, the impossible timing, the truly chilling moments, the sharpness of it, and the unbelievably cozy, timeless world it creates. ”
ABOUT THE HOSTS:
ABOUT THE SHOW:
NO NOTES is a monthly spin-off of the Guilty Pleasures podcast. Twice a month, the Guilty Pleasures crew will alternate between dissecting a “so bad it’s good” guilty pleasure voted on by our listeners and an example of cinematic excellence and near-flawless execution, as selected by one of our hosts.
Each month, your hosts, Kelly, Jack, and Stephanie, take a deep dive into a 21st Century “Guilty Pleasure” horror movie as chosen by you, the listener, in an online poll (based on a particular theme). Join us for thematic cocktails, laughter, and a shared love of deliciously cheesy horror served up hot and tasty.
Guilty Pleasures: Holiday Special Featuring “Elves”
In this holiday extravaganza episode of Guilty Pleasures, join hosts Stephanie, Kelly, and our newest addition, Jonathan (Jack was tied up in tinsel and couldn't join us), as they unwrap the bizarre and unhinged world of holiday cinema. They dive into the depths of Elves, a film that's as chaotic as it is entertaining. It's a sleigh full of questionable decisions, diabolical dialogue, absurd plot twists, wildly offensive antics, and unhinged holiday mischief.
And that's not all! In the second half of the podcast, join your festive cinephile friends for a look at four more ”nutty as a fruitcake” holiday treats: A New York Christmas Wedding, Elf Bowling, A Medea Christmas, and Jack Frost. Plus, we each offer a bonus Christmas flick guaranteed to make you say, ”Ho, Ho, HO-LY Hell!”
Expect laughter, disbelief, and a spirited debate about what truly makes a movie a guilty pleasure. Don't miss this festive journey through the weirdest corners of holiday films!
Episode play icon
In this holiday extravaganza episode of Guilty Pleasures, join hosts Stephanie, Kelly, and our newest addition, Jonathan (Jack was tied up in tinsel and couldn't [...]
December 24, 2025
Episode play icon
Hey, hey, hey, a wild ride is on the way with this episode of Guilty Pleasures! Join Stephanie, Jack, and Kelly as they take a [...]
February 10, 2025
Episode play icon
Welcome to another episode of No Notes, where Stephanie, Kelly, and Jack take a break from dissecting guilty pleasures to delve into some cinematic treasures. [...]
December 24, 2024
Search Results placeholder
…
Our Instagram handles are:
Morbidly Beautiful @morbidlybeautifulhorror | Stephanie @srgreenhaw | Jack @jack_wells_author | Kelly @kellyemintzer
Follow Morbidly Beautiful on Twitter @xmorbidbeautyx or on Facebook.
CREDITS
Special thanks to the wildly talented Morgan Quaid for our theme show music. Morgan is a multi-talented author of books and graphic novels, a popular podcaster, and a badass musician. Please support this lovely human by subscribing to his channel on YouTube at youtube.com/@MorgantheQuaid.
Rediscovering the Timeless Charm of ‘Arsenic and Old Lace’
In this episode, Kelly takes us on a nostalgic journey with Frank Capra’s timeless classic, “Arsenic and Old Lace.” Join us as we explore the film’s genius, from Cary Grant’s unparalleled comedic performance to the cozy, timeless world Capra creates.
We delve into the film’s meta humor, the charmingly macabre antics of the Brewster family, and the endearing madness that envelops everyone who steps into their home. With its pitch-perfect comedic timing, clever writing, and stellar cast, “Arsenic and Old Lace” proves to be a masterpiece that continues to enchant audiences.
So grab a cup of hot cocoa, snuggle under a blanket, and embrace the delightful madness of this cinematic gem. No notes!
—
Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/guilty-pleasures-film/support
Follow Us!