In our next Cage Match, we visit one of Cage’s most recent roles as a devoted father in the post-apocalyptic survival horror film “Arcadian”.
No time to read? Click the button below to listen to this post.
IN THIS CORNER: KELLY MINTZER
The Lowdown
I have truly excellent news for anyone who feels like I’ve been running long on my reviews lately: I don’t have a ton to say about Arcadian.
Arcadian is incredibly fine. It’s aggressively ok! It feels sort of like A Quiet Place Babies (a cartoon I would most certainly watch), a very YA approach to the post-apocalypse. Nic Cage plays a grizzled yet loving dad to two boys in a dangerous landscape. He is protective, though he gives the boys a reasonably long leash. The boys fall into pretty standard young adult archetypes; Joseph is curious, clever, and obedient. Thomas is more rebellious and adventurous. The three live in a house fortified to keep out the nocturnal creatures that haunt the countryside at night.
If this all sounds pretty bog standard, that’s because it is.
I wish I had something incisive to say about it; I don’t. The movie feels a bit like a first draft; there are plenty of good ideas that should have been fleshed out more (I particularly noted the part where, after Nicolas Cage is badly injured, Thomas sets out to get him medicine— as if there is but one medicine, and it cures all).
Perhaps if I were younger, this movie would have hit harder for me. As it stood, the teenage dynamic didn’t do a hell of a lot for me, and it’s the vast majority of the movie. Nic Cage is taken out of commission relatively early on, with a triumphant return at the end that only reinforced that I would have liked him to be in it more.
The Cage Factor:
This is actually kind of a hard one for me because I think Nicolas Cage turned in a beautiful, restrained performance in Arcadian. But there’s not enough of him in it by a long measure. I am going with Cautious Cage. Let me explain. If it were based solely on Nic’s performance, this movie would be essential. It continues his latter-day career trajectory of beautiful, subtle performances. However, you have to watch the movie to enjoy it. And the movie is just…meh. Shrug.
It’s a movie you can happily put on in the background while you’re doing something else, and you’ll like it just fine, but I doubt anyone will rush to recommend it to their friends. I do think it’s worth it for Nicolas Cage’s performance, provided you keep your expectations in check. But it’s a mostly forgettable entry in an expansive filmography with much better options to cull from.
AND IN THIS CORNER: STEPHANIE MALONE
The Lowdown
Arcadian, the 2024 horror film directed by Benjamin Brewer, is a gripping and inventive addition to the post-apocalyptic survival horror genre.
Set in a nightmarish future where humanity struggles to survive against mysterious nocturnal predators, Arcadian follows Paul (Nicolas Cage) and his teenage sons, Joseph (Jaeden Martell) and Thomas (Maxwell Jenkins). The family ekes out an existence on their isolated farm, venturing out only during daylight hours to scavenge for supplies and staying locked in their fortified home at night to avoid the deadly creatures that hunt in the darkness.
While Cage’s screen time may be less than expected, his portrayal of Paul anchors the film emotionally. He brings a weary gravitas to the role of a father desperately trying to protect his sons in an unforgiving world. Cage’s performance is nuanced and restrained for much of the film, making his eventual unleashing of “Caginess” in the frenetic finale all the more impactful and satisfying.
The film takes its time in the first half to establish compelling and believable characters, allowing the audience to form a strong connection with the family. This investment pays off handsomely in the latter half, as the intensifying danger ratchets up the tension to nail-biting levels. Jaeden Martell and Maxwell Jenkins deliver standout performances as the brothers, and their complex relationship and individual struggles add depth to the family drama.
When the film finally embraces its monster movie roots, it does so with gusto.
While it may not quite rise to the level of a modern classic, Arcadian comfortably resides above the standard indie horror fare by delivering a genre mashup that truly works. It offers the scares and thrills horror fans crave while providing a surprisingly effective character drama at its core.
The Cage Factor:
Nicolas Cage’s performance in Arcadian is a testament to his versatility and depth as an actor. While his screen time may be limited, his presence looms large over the entire film, providing a strong emotional anchor that elevates the narrative. As the protective father figure, Cage brings a nuanced and understated gravitas to the role. His portrayal of a man worn down by the constant struggle for survival yet driven by an unwavering love for his sons lends a poignant authenticity to the post-apocalyptic setting.
What makes Cage’s performance particularly effective is how he modulates his intensity throughout the film. He maintains a tightly controlled demeanor for much of the runtime, conveying volumes through subtle facial expressions and measured line delivery. This restrained approach makes the moments when he does unleash his trademark intensity all the more impactful. In the film’s frenetic finale, Cage finally lets loose with the kind of manic energy his fans have come to love, but it feels earned and organic within the story’s context.
This calculated buildup and release of tension in Cage’s performance mirrors the film’s overall structure, contributing significantly to its emotional resonance and nail-biting climax.
Even in scenes where he’s not physically present, the specter of Cage’s character influences the actions and decisions of the other characters, underscoring his importance to both the narrative and thematic elements of the film.
Follow Us!